Disneyland

I’d like to kick off this post with an assurance that I will be publishing the next installment of Reader Request Month: 2 Fast 2 Furious in the next day or two. I foolishly thought that I could keep up with my blogging even when, over the course of a week, my niece was born, I started a new job, and I departed for “the happiest place on Earth.” When I returned from Disneyland, I needed some time to settle into my new routine, but I should be on track to resume my regular schedule of weekend posts.

Back when I was a kid, I used to watch a commercial for Disney World on our Lion King VHS. As a five-year-old, I didn’t really understand the irony that made the ad funny, but I did know that I wanted to go to that park… or maybe the other one. I wasn’t sure at the time whether Disneyland or Disney World was actually closer. Not that it mattered; all I knew was that one day, I was going to visit Mickey and my beloved princesses.

Nineteen years later, that day arrived. I was initially worried that going to Disneyland for the first time as an adult would ruin my experience. This seemed even more likely in light of the fact that I’ve analyzed the very same princesses that I grew up blindly idolizing. Faced with the Disney machine, would I be able to enjoy the magical kingdom populated by characters I’ve loved for decades, or would I see only the money-making ploys of a corporate giant cashing in on manufactured nostalgia? The answer, it turns out, was both. Often at the same time. (In the interest of staying on topic, I’ll talk about only those things that relate to the characters we’ve discussed here on the blog.)

When I arrived at my hotel, one of the first things that caught my attention was a framed picture of the first six princesses: five white women and Jasmine. That proved to be the case throughout the park; most products only acknowledged the existence of eight princesses, invariably excluding Pocahontas and Mulan. Merida, having debuted after the success of Tangled made Rapunzel a necessary addition to any group photo, was left out, but still featured on a lot of Brave-specific merchandise. I knew that I would be leaving with some of it. But from the time I walked into the World of Disney store on the first day, I also knew that I was going to make it my mission to find things relating to Mulan and Pocahontas. When it came to merchandise, I was largely unsuccessful. Even in the land of imagination, it seems that no one can imagine people wanting products depicting all the princesses.

In the park’s major shows, however, I managed to find an interesting trend. In Mickey’s Soundsational Parade, Tiana gets her own float. In the abbreviated live musical version of Aladdin, Jasmine has a solo, “To Be Free”. Pocahontas has a featured segment in the World of Color show. She, Mulan, and Tiana all make an appearance in Mickey and the Magical Map. Disney is fine marketing an overwhelmingly white set of princesses to the masses, but when it comes to the parks, it seems that the company feels a need to stand by its claims of diversity and imagination. Sort of.

Mickey and the Magical Map involves Mickey, a mapmaker’s apprentice, trying to fill in an unfinished spot on said map. The dot jumps around the world, taking Mickey to the locations of several Disney films. After King Louie finished telling the audience how much he wanted to be like us, the dot took Mickey to the setting of Pocahontas… and Mulan… and Tangled… simultaneously. Having seen only a few items of merchandise featuring Mulan and absolutely no mention of her otherwise, I was willing to ignore the seeming collapse of time and space in order to hear “Reflection,” one of my all-time favourite Disney songs. Then Rapunzel and Flynn showed up, and both Mulan and Pocahontas were suddenly incorporated into a love song and lost in a sea of lanterns. Mickey’s final destination was Hawaii, where Stitch appeared without Lilo or Nani, despite the fact that they, and not he, are native to the area. It’s a bit of a mess, and it proves that even in a show intended to illustrate Disney’s diversity, they still prefer to feature the popular characters that are already featured elsewhere.

Yet I found that some of my favourite memories of the trip came as a result of Disney’s marketing machine. All around the park, I saw hundreds of little girls wearing princess costumes. Those who wore Tiana’s outfit reminded me that, despite the film’s flaws, Tiana herself is worth looking up to. One particularly memorable group of girls stood in front of me in the line to meet Merida, each one sporting dyed red hair and an official dress, clearly excited to meet their favourite character. I myself made a Build-a-Bear and named her after the princess of the Clan Dunbroch.

My favourite memory, however, is of standing in the audience for World of Color, watching scenes from the films of my childhood, when suddenly there was the image of a red-haired girl and dozens of little voices exclaiming, “Merida!” As an adult, I connected to Merida immediately, but I found her more compelling the more profoundly I considered the critical work being performed by her story. Hearing a bunch of kids express such utter joy at seeing her made me remember what it was like to love Belle, simply because she was awesome. Like the older brother said in that commercial, it really brought out the kid in me.

Revival

In 1989, following a number of losses in box office showdowns against the defected Don Bluth, Disney was in desperate need of a major success to save their foundering animation department. So, thirty years after the release of Sleeping Beauty, the company revived the Disney princess, and the release of The Little Mermaid marked the beginning of a ten-year period which has come to be known as the Disney Renaissance. It was followed by Beauty and the Beast in 1991, and Aladdin in 1992. While it took Disney over twenty-two years to establish their princesses, it only took three years (plus production time) to update them for a modern audience.

Because we were born in the year of Disney’s rebirth, the three princesses we will be discussing this week were omnipresent throughout our childhoods and are near and dear to our hearts. As a baby, Megan was lulled to sleep by her mother singing “Part of Your World,” and Ashley once watched The Little Mermaid six times in a single day. Ashley asked for Belle’s library for Christmas when she was five. Watching Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas was the most traumatic experience of Megan’s life up to that point. Megan’s younger sister desperately wanted a pet tiger entirely thanks to Rajah.

Now, twenty years later, we want to break through our nostalgic remembrances and find out whether the characters themselves are as strong as our childhood attachment to them.

Ariel

Ariel’s debut marks a real change in the Disney princess model: the development of a personality. Unlike her ostensibly perfect predecessors, Ariel is introduced in a scene which highlights her imperfections. Although she has a beautiful voice, she can’t be bothered to show up for rehearsals or, indeed, major concerts which are designed around her. Instead, she spends her time lifting human artifacts from shipwrecks and ignoring her friend’s warnings of danger. She is foolishly fearless, exceedingly curious, hopelessly naïve, and intensely emotional. She is, in short, the breath of fresh air needed to revive the princess brand.

Her freshness lasts through her “I Want” song, in which she reveals her desire to experience every facet of human life. She collects souvenirs of this place she cannot visit with the same dedication as any particularly obsessed Trekkie or Whovian; unlike them, however, she knows that her other world actually exists as more than the escape she imagines it to be. Equating life on the surface with freedom from her father’s restrictive rules, she imagines it as a paradise where “they understand/ That they don't reprimand their daughters/ Bright young women, sick of swimmin'/ Ready to stand.” More than a mysterious physical location, the human world is the realm of adulthood. This father-daughter conflict could easily have driven the plot, but that would have been a deviation from both the Disney princess formula and the original Hans Christian Andersen fairy tale (because fidelity to source material is obviously Disney’s strong point).

No sooner has Ariel completed her plea to become “part of your world” than we learn its intended audience: the first conventionally attractive human man she sees. Here we do have to give her credit for saving Prince Eric’s life, which is more than the earlier princesses ever did. What we don’t have to give the film credit for is the way in which both Ariel and Eric become obsessed with each other, Eric desperately searching for a beautiful voice and Ariel translating all of her humanity-related desires into desire for one human. She has always viewed humanity through the things it produces; with Eric, she is saved the trouble of making him into an object to collect, as she has found a guy that has already been made into a statue. It is only when she loses the statue that she must collect the man.

From the moment Ariel lays eyes on Eric, things go downhill. Quickly. The moment Triton finds out, however, things hit rock bottom.

Yes, we’re talking about the real change to the princess model: the deal with the devil. This is perhaps the most contentious aspect of Ariel’s character; in essence, she sacrifices her voice and her familial relationships for a dude. This is also the moment when Ariel exercises the greatest agency, because Disney apparently wants to make our jobs more difficult. With the loss of her voice also comes the loss of her agency, as she spends much of the rest of the film waiting for things to happen to her. She can only will Eric to kiss her and, when he is manipulated into an engagement with Vanessa, she waits for others to stall the ceremony. The otherwise useless Scuttle rallies a veritable army of sea creatures to terrorize the wedding ship, and Flounder transports Ariel to the event. Because the former mermaid cannot swim, apparently.


Although Ariel doesn’t really do much of anything, what is more troubling is that she doesn’t change. King Triton, not Ariel, develops from an overly controlling xenophobe to a more tolerant person willing to trust his child to know what is best for her. When he offers himself in Ariel’s place, she makes no protest against a decision which would have disastrous results for the entire undersea population. She is the reason for Ursula’s ascension to power, but she is not responsible for remedying this mistake. Instead, Eric impales Ursula on the bow of a ship while Ariel lies stranded at the bottom of a whirlpool to be shot at like the proverbial fish in a barrel. At least this time the prince can aim his phallic symbol on his own. We just wish that the main character had done it instead.

Verdict: Strong Female Character™

Belle

(Disclaimer: While we are trying our best to be objective in writing this blog, we must admit in the interest of full disclosure that Belle is the Princess of Our Hearts. She’s the princess we identified with and idolized as children. That’s why we had to use an example involving Megan’s sister to discuss Aladdin, because when that film came out, we were still too busy being besotted with Belle to notice Jasmine.)

Whereas The Little Mermaid marks the revival of the Disney princess, Beauty and the Beast represents its true renaissance.

Belle is the first princess who is not the recipient or victim of a magic spell; like the princes, she is fated to break the curse, which, for once, does not specifically involve a kiss. Belle is introduced in a song which tells us simultaneously what she thinks of her “poor, provincial town” and what said town thinks of her. A bookworm stuck in what is made out to be the least literate village in France, she is considered odd. Because of this, she has a difficult time making personal connections with any of her neighbours. There is a general air of disapproval from the townspeople, as though her beauty is tarnished by her strangeness (basically, “Pretty girl -- real shame about that whole possessing a personality thing”).
The content of her “I Want” song, then, comes as no surprise. After Gaston’s proposal, during which he and the townspeople are disappointed to learn that Belle doesn’t want him, she describes her real desires:

Is he gone? Can you imagine?
"Madame Gaston!"
He asked me to marry him.

Me, the wife of that boorish, brainless...

Can't you just see it?

"Madame Gaston!"

His "little wife"

No sir! Not me!

I guarantee it

I want much more than this provincial life

I want adventure in the great wide somewhere

I want it more than I can tell

And for once it might be grand

To have someone understand

I want so much more than they've got planned

First, we see that Belle has no interest in looks, making her a far cry from Ariel, whose eyes practically bug out of her head when she first sees Eric. Belle is not merely rejecting Gaston, the undisputed town heartthrob, but the whole idea of settling down into a traditional domestic role. Her focus then shifts from what she could not bear to what she actually wants: adventures, presumably like the ones in her books. And here it is interesting to note that Belle is our first genre-savvy princess, who identifies her favourite part of her favourite book thusly: “Here’s where she meets Prince Charming, but she won’t discover that it’s him ‘til Chapter 3.”  The song takes a much more personal turn in its final lines, as Belle reveals the profound loneliness which leads her to ask not for a handsome prince, but merely for someone who understands her and her dreams. Were this anything but a princess movie, that person could be a best friend of either gender; because it is, though, we know the person in question is a guy. 

There are two men involved in Belle’s defining moment: the one she is saving and the one she is going to save. Unlike Ariel, Belle is willing to sacrifice herself to save her father, even with full knowledge of  the beastly nature and appearance of her warden. One of the criticisms lodged against this film is the accusation of Stockholm Syndrome, suggesting that Belle becomes sympathetic to her captor and tolerates the Beast’s abuse. When her curiosity leads her to the West Wing and an encounter with the Beast’s rage issues, however, she is hardly tolerant. She runs from the castle, preserving her own safety, “promise or no promise,” proving herself to be self-sacrificing, but not up to the point of stupidity. Encountering wolves in the forest, she attempts to fight them off using a tree branch, showing her to be a very different character than Snow White, who merely covered her eyes as if that might be enough to ward off daggers. The Beast swoops in to save her, as we know a prince should, but the remarkable thing is that Belle saves him when it would benefit her to let him die. She is downright heroic.

This is the most fundamental difference between Belle and her predecessors: she is the hero of her story. She displays tremendous bravery on multiple occasions, and she is the one who must break the spell. She’s even the first princess with a horse, heretofore the exclusive territory of princes.
And she has a library. There is nothing cooler than that library.

Verdict: Actual strong female character.

Jasmine

Jasmine is the first princess who is not referenced in the title and is therefore the first to be a legitimate supporting character. What is perhaps most interesting about her is the way in which she resists being reduced to a pawn in someone else’s game.

Jasmine is the sheltered daughter of the Sultan, who informs us during her first scene that she has not only never had a human friend but has never been outside the palace walls. She doesn’t let a little thing like having no idea how anything works in the real world stop her, though, and soon escapes to the marketplace. There she meets Aladdin, who bails her out of a sticky situation with a plan that requires her to think on her toes; she demonstrates her ability to adapt, an ability which she doesn’t really get a chance to use as she almost immediately outs herself as the princess in order to save him. This is a major change from the other princesses: Jasmine knows that she has power and she is completely willing to use it.

Despite having power, however, she lacks control over her own life. She is being forced to marry according to a law her father hasn’t quite realized he can change, and she does not hesitate to point out the unfairness of a life without choice. Choice is the operative word for Jasmine; although she does not get an official “I Want” song, one could easily imagine that it would be about freedom to decide things for herself. She resents the patriarchal model that allows her father, his advisor, and her suitor to finagle a deal for her hand, shouting, “How dare you, all of you, standing around deciding my future?  I am not a prize to be won!” Jasmine has a tendency to deliver these kinds of outbursts, stepping into a room, telling everyone that she is not an object, and then leaving the men to continue fighting over her. While she does eventually exercise her power of choice -- “I choose you, Aladdin” -- she does serve as a sort of prize, as Aladdin had to defeat Jafar in order to win her.

That does not mean that she’s not willing to manipulate other people. On two occasions, we see Jasmine break out the feminine wiles. She attempts to lure Aladdin into admitting his lie and manages to distract Jafar as Aladdin sneaks back into the palace. In neither case is she entirely successful, so we’re not really sure why this was even included. Is the film suggesting that using womanly tricks is a valid method when one has no other options, or is the failure of her technique a condemnation of the use of feminine wiles?

This is Aladdin’s primary motivation. He wants freedom and riches, but what he really wants is Jasmine. He tailors his seduction techniques (and the song that facilitates them) to Jasmine’s desires; she must “let [her] heart decide” to see a “whole new world” with him. It’s choice and freedom, wrapped up in a magic carpet. Also, unlike The Little Mermaid, in which Ariel must transform herself into a completely different species in order to get the guy, in this film Aladdin changes himself in order to impress Jasmine. This doesn’t work. When they first meet, Jasmine is utterly unimpressed by Prince Ali’s obnoxious show of wealth and his over-inflated sense of entitlement, and she continues to be less than taken with Ali until he admits to being the “street rat” she had met in the marketplace. She requires honesty and hates being manipulated. 

Verdict: Supporting role (albeit a strong one).

Conclusion

We found writing this post to be exceedingly difficult, as if the forces of nostalgia were preventing us from replacing our rose-coloured glasses with the cold lens of critical analysis. For many of us, these characters were among our best childhood friends, and it’s troubling to think that they may have led us astray. Still, this group demonstrates a marked development from the princesses of the ‘30s and ‘50s, reflecting the the influence of the feminist movement. Although the princesses’ stories still revolve around men, they all look for (an often nebulous) something more. They reject authority and demonstrate that it is not only people, but social conventions, that can restrict freedom. Perhaps most importantly, however, they pave the way for the next set of characters, and what we see as the zenith of the Disney princess.